In this new Fifth Gear segment, Tiff Needell and Jason Plato pit the McLaren MP4-12C up against Ferrari’s 458 Italia. Surprisingly enough, the winner isn’t who you expect. Continue reading to see why.

Both drivers render the same verdict, and it’s the kind of final assessment you don’t often get from motoring shows: one wins on paper, then gets trounced once they discard the spec sheet and grab the wheel.

[via Autoblog]