Yes, that is actually a Nicolas Cage lookalike from 1870. However, that isn’t the only celebrity who just might be a time traveler, as we’ve rounded up ten more coincidences that are too bizarre to explain. Continue reading to see them all.

10. Brad Pitt

9. John Travolta

8. Eddie Murphy

7. Sylvester Stallone

6. Mark Zuckerberg

5. Justin Timberlake

4. Christian Bale

3. Jean-Ralphio

2. Orlando Bloom

1. Keanu Reeves

[Sources 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5]