It was a routine fishing trip for a Florida shrimper until…an incredibly rare Goblin Shark showed up off the coast of Key West, Florida, on April 19. Carl Moore said: “I didn’t even know what it was. I didn’t get the tape measure out because that thing’s got some wicked teeth, they could do some damage.” There’s a happy ending for both parties as Moore decided to throw it back in the ocean after snapping the picture you see above. Continue reading for a video and more information.

According to the NOAA, Moore didn’t report the extremely rare find until Thursday – the 18-foot-long shark is only the second ever seen in the Gulf. They’re most commonly found off the coast of Japan, says the Houston Chronicle reports, and are normally “pinkish white” in color with bluish fins.